GLAAD Is Sad Over A&E's Decision to Reverse Suspension of Duck Dynasty's Phil Robertson

A few years ago, I couldn't imagine a network disregarding GLAAD's recommendations
Phil v. The Gays. With which will we side? Or rather, against which will we side? This is the question that society demands we answer. Are we anti-Phil or anti-gay or anti-GLAAD or anti-A&E or anti- ... ?
Perhaps no other word sums up the Duck Dynasty fiasco as aptly as the word "anti."
Whenever I hear that someone is anti-this or that, I immediately think of the old quip about MADD - are there any mothers for drunk driving? - and ask myself if anyone is really in favor of the particular thing being protested. Since GLAAD has recently taken a hard-line stance against Phil Robertson's "anti-gay" comments, I've been asking myself a similar question about defamation: Who among us is for it? Most of us are decidedly against defamation, although we choose not to publicly participate in institutional demonstrations to prove how against it we are. But, of course, GLAAD is an institution, and therefore their criticism reverberates at systemic levels.
Founded in 1985 in the wake of the AIDS crisis, GLAAD was formed to protest skewed coverage of LGBT issues and "to put pressure on media organizations to end homophobic reporting." The original name was an acronym for "Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation," and although the organization has recently rebranded itself by deciding that the letters G-L-A-A-D aren't actually going to stand for anything any more, their reputation for protesting defamatory speech is well known both within and without the LGBT community.
It goes without saying that GLAAD has done a great deal of good for the LGBT community, and for that they deserve our applause and honor. As they noted in their announcement heralding their name change, their work continues to educate and influence the greater culture. Historically they've been a symbol of inclusion and tolerance, and they've worked tirelessly to infuse these values into our controlling media discourses. Frankly, though, I don't think their hasty reaction to Phil Robertson displayed our LGBT community's best values.
Before many of us even learned that Phil Robertson was interviewed by GQ, GLAAD had already convinced us that Phil's words were vile and offensive, and called upon A&E "to re-examine their ties to someone with such public disdain for LGBT people and families." (I still wonder how many of us - commentators included - have read the actual story in GQ.) A&E offered its own kneejerk response to GLAAD's kneejerk response, and placed Phil on "indefinite" hiatus, which then prompted some Evangelicals to offer up their own kneejerk response which had something to do with the freedom of speech and now - did I hear this correctly? - Chick-fil-A. In the end, after carefully reviewing all of the responses, A&E issued a final response explaining their decision to lift Phil's suspension, which resulted in yet another predictable response from GLAAD. I'm not sure how we do it, but we manage to craft responses to our opponents without ever having actual conversations with them.
It isn't shocking that a conservative Christian duck-hunter from Louisiana has opinions that GLAAD deemed "anti-gay," and it isn't shocking that A&E immediately kowtowed to GLAAD at the first drop of the word "homophobic." What is shocking, however, is that A&E lifted Phil's hiatus in spite of the fact that they knew GLAAD wasn't going to be happy about it. A few years ago, I couldn't imagine a network disregarding GLAAD's recommendations. A&E is certainly setting a precedent - which makes me wonder about where we are today with queer politics.
Click here to read more.
SOURCE: TIME Magazine
Brandon Ambrosino is a writer and professional dancer based in Baltimore.

Views: 45

Comment

You need to be a member of The Oracle to add comments!

Join The Oracle

The Oracle Magazine is a Hip-Hop magazine and Social Community with industry news, music, videos, photos, Health Tips,discussions and more!

Please Contact Us At

                  Call or Text: 424-644-9089
             Email: Theoraclemag@gmail.com

Daily Devotional

Latest Activity

Prince Malachi The First's 6 blog posts were featured
3 hours ago
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
3 hours ago
Prince Malachi The First's video was featured

NEW Christian Rap | Brian Todd - No Games ft. SbTone 4one8 (Music Video)[Christian Music] #CHH

NEW ALBUM "AGAINST ALL ODDS" OUT NOW EVERYWHERE http://itunes.apple.com/album/id/1492969327 CHECK OUT NEW VIDEOS AND SUBSCRIBE TO OUR YOUTUBE CHANEL: https:/...
7 hours ago
Prince Malachi The First posted a video

NEW Christian Rap | Brian Todd - No Games ft. SbTone 4one8 (Music Video)[Christian Music] #CHH

NEW ALBUM "AGAINST ALL ODDS" OUT NOW EVERYWHERE http://itunes.apple.com/album/id/1492969327 CHECK OUT NEW VIDEOS AND SUBSCRIBE TO OUR YOUTUBE CHANEL: https:/...
7 hours ago
Prince Malachi The First's 2 blog posts were featured
yesterday
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
yesterday
Prince Malachi The First's 4 blog posts were featured
Saturday
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Saturday
Prince Malachi The First's 5 blog posts were featured
Friday
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Friday
Prince Malachi The First's 6 blog posts were featured
Thursday
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Thursday
Prince Malachi The First's 5 blog posts were featured
Wednesday
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Wednesday
Prince Malachi The First's 3 blog posts were featured
Feb 17
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Feb 17
Prince Malachi The First's 4 blog posts were featured
Feb 16
Prince Malachi The First posted blog posts
Feb 16
Prince Malachi The First's video was featured

Ty Brasel - "The Power" feat. KB (Official Music Video) #CHH #ChristianHipHop #ChristianRap #gospelrap #holyhiphop #hiphop

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
Feb 16
Prince Malachi The First posted a video

Ty Brasel - "The Power" feat. KB (Official Music Video)

Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
Feb 16

Look for THE ORACLE On Facebook and Twitter!

Birthdays

Birthdays Tomorrow

Events

© 2020   Created by Prince Malachi The First.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service